Tomahawk Nation: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: College Football Preseason Top 25 Rankings

Clemson's Andre Branch Should Be Suspended For Cowardly Eye-Gouge

Update: This has been picked up by Sports Illustrated, via Andy Staples, and The Sporting News, via Chris Littman

Here's the Clemson reaction, courtesy Shakin' The Southland

With all the attention given to the Brandon Spikes eye gouge incident last week against Georgia, why has this cheap shot not received any attention?  Start to watch at the 0:04 mark, Andre Branch (#40) grabs #79 (David Spurlock) by the helmet, snaps his neck back, holds his head and sticks his fingers into Spurlock's facemask, an obvious eye gouge.   Then Branch gets up, talks trash to the justifiably angry Spurlock, points to the sky, and dances around.  Spurlock shows a ton of restraint by not going after Branch for this classless cheap shot.

If you are at work and can't watch video clips, here is a screenshot (click to enlarge):

Branch_eye_gouge_medium

Kwb04110899a_medium

The ACC should take action and suspend this "athlete."    Someone is going to lose their sight as a result of these cowardly and completely non-football related acts.  I wonder what Clemson head coach Dabo Swinney thinks of this?  I wonder what the ACC office thinks about this?

0 recs  |  Comment 155 comments |

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

He was just caught up in the moment.

He’s a great competitor and wants to win. Spurlock shouldn’t have put his eye’s into Andre Branch’s fingers anyway.

by coonhound on Nov 10, 2009 3:18 PM EST reply actions  

I know Spurlock did the right thing by basically doing nothing but I wish he had beaten the grap out of Branch and then blamed the refs for not doing their job in the postgame. Unfotunately we’d lose him for at least game and then some so it’d be counter productive. If I ruled the world it would be ok though.

by evenflow58 on Nov 10, 2009 3:33 PM EST reply actions  

Self control

I’d have cup checked him.

by Marmaduke1 on Nov 10, 2009 3:36 PM EST reply actions   1 recs

SOMEONE ALERT HEATHER DINICH

Co-conductor of the "Kirby Smart for DC 2010" Train!!!!

by NoleThruandThru on Nov 10, 2009 3:44 PM EST reply actions  

What if we posted box scores of our final games as if they had already happened

You’ve been dang near right on all of them so far, Bud. It might be in poor taste given that our players are still playing and growing. But in reality, our season is over.

by ricobert1 on Nov 10, 2009 4:07 PM EST up reply actions  

Hmm... ok,

Wake 42, FSU 24
Not sure on Maryland
FSU 7, UF 56 (but I expect them to get a TD on every drive, but for our offense to play pile pus’s like UT’s did and just milk clock starting in the 1st quarter).

by Bud Elliott on Nov 10, 2009 4:10 PM EST up reply actions  

Wow

Then he has the nerve to trash talk and give the “our ball!” motion. Here’s to an ACL tear next week for that thug.

by tdchrisdavis on Nov 10, 2009 3:48 PM EST reply actions  

I called Tonya Harding

Apparently she’s still claiming innocence…..so we’ll have to leave it up to karma….

by PBD on Nov 10, 2009 3:54 PM EST up reply actions  

No doubt the guy is pure trash. He deserves to have a bat taken to his knee cap.

by Q-tip Motha on Nov 10, 2009 4:20 PM EST up reply actions  

Yes lets overreact

because if it had happened the other way around you would not be asking for your player to have a bat taken to his kneecap.

He should be suspended, whether its an attempt at an eye-gouge or an attempt to injure the guy’s neck.

by DrB on Nov 10, 2009 4:45 PM EST up reply actions  

Let someone snap your head back and try n eye gouge ya

And then tell me how you would feel about it. What injury would be worse, a snapped neck/eye injury or busted knee cap?

by CSI Nole on Nov 10, 2009 4:51 PM EST up reply actions  

I have had it happen to me

and I still wouldnt tell somebody to take out his kneecap. I’d let my teammates know and then they’ll take care of it on the field. You don’t know if it did get taken care of on the field, there is no video.

What I said is that he deserves public punishment for it, and thats fair and will do more good to stop it from happening again, reacting with anger will just prompt one of your players to do something to someone else who doesnt deserve it.

by DrB on Nov 10, 2009 4:59 PM EST up reply actions  

Yes, he deserves to be suspended. Let’s see what Coach Swinney has to say about it.

by CSI Nole on Nov 10, 2009 5:07 PM EST up reply actions  

Spurlock still should have beaten him

That way we would have won something in that game.

Ok maybe that was harsh but this “athlete” isn’t even on par with a Brandon Spikes and plus it was a “media darling” gaytor that did it so the public outcry will not be as loud. Even still he should get chewed out by Mike Golic and some sort of a suspension.

by lildrunknole on Nov 10, 2009 9:26 PM EST up reply actions  

LETS OVERREACT WOOOOOOOOOOO

I dont like the cut of your jib sir. This post is about as meaningful as yours. Reflection purposes maybe?

"I'm falling apart, I'm barely breathing, With a broken heart thats still beating, In the pain is the healing, in Your Name I find meaning, So I'm holdin' on.. holdin' on to you."

by FSUvaFan on Nov 10, 2009 7:15 PM EST up reply actions  

I don't think anyone caught it til recently

Not only did he try the eye gouge but to snap his neck back at the same time? Talk about class… less.

by CSI Nole on Nov 10, 2009 4:22 PM EST up reply actions  

To make matters worse

I believe the purple jacket dude holding them back is their team chaplain. Man that’s classy when you need to be restrained by your teams chaplain.

by revival on Nov 10, 2009 9:32 PM EST up reply actions  

DrB

Number 99 looks a lot like Jarvis Jenkins to me.

Jarvis Jenkins is listed as a true junior by the Clemson athletic’s site.
It also reports Andre Branch as a redshirt sophomore. Rivals reports that they came in in the recruiting class of 2007. Clemson is wearing their home uniforms so I take it this was from a year that is an even number, most likely a home game. This year you play at U.S.C. which means that last year must have been a home game. The picture could have been from 2006. The picture was definitely not from 2004, because well I don’t think that needs to be explained.
It could not be 2002 because you wore white pants in that game and did not have the white stripe going down the axillary(armpit) area. So this picture is either from 2006 or 2008. Jenkins could have only played in the 2008 one since he came in the class of 2007 with Branch. I don’t know if Brandon Thompson changed his number from 99 to 98, may be it could be him but he is a sophomore and came in a year after Jenkins and Branch. In that case it would definitely be 2008. Branch is listed as #40, I do not know if he has changed it over his career.

by revival on Nov 10, 2009 6:28 PM EST up reply actions  

I stand corrected

I thought the picture was from the 2004 fight, but it is last year. My mistake.

I thought I had photoshopped this picture before last years Caroilna game, but it was right afterwards. I forget what it was that Carolina did to initiate the tussle, I think something about dancing on the TigerPaw.

by DrB on Nov 10, 2009 7:38 PM EST up reply actions  

No worries

Tensions have been on the rise, understandable confusion.

by revival on Nov 10, 2009 7:43 PM EST up reply actions  

I never harbored any ill will towards CU until this game. Now they aren’t far behind the goaters on my shcittlist.

Ameica, Land of the free and home to the entitled.

by levynole on Nov 10, 2009 5:06 PM EST reply actions  

Could F$U be more bitchy

Seriously folks, quit whining about how Clemson played rough with you. It’s a man’s sport and unfortunately for F$U fans, your team is playing like girls this year. Could you whine any more? Maybe McDaniel should be suspended for playing too rough with Ponder too? It’s a joke what your program and fans have become.

by F$Uisabitch on Nov 10, 2009 5:17 PM EST reply actions  

Hmmm

You’re right, I forgot to add the McDaniel part.

Or perhaps I focused on the part that was completely unrelated to the game.

by Bud Elliott on Nov 10, 2009 5:20 PM EST up reply actions  

Oh,

and thanks for holding our spot in the ACC until we joined.

by Bud Elliott on Nov 10, 2009 5:20 PM EST up reply actions  

Thanks for joining

Really looking to more insightful analysis from you.

by RaysnNoles on Nov 10, 2009 5:27 PM EST up reply actions  

Someone quoting a man's sport

and then you join SBNation just to complain about a dirty play your team committed. Look in the mirror before you call someone a girl.

by 1newplayer on Nov 10, 2009 5:27 PM EST up reply actions  

eye scratching is typical associated with women's fighting style.

There’s a reason it was the only illegal move during UFC’s early years. Even kicking a downed opponent in the head was legal back then.
Also, maybe take the word “bitch” out of your screenname. It doesn’t scream “class”.

by The K-Man on Nov 10, 2009 5:41 PM EST via mobile up reply actions  

Classless fan here

and classless athlete doing the eye gouging. Perfect combination :)

by Cee on Nov 10, 2009 5:46 PM EST up reply actions  

Could use your forensic skills licenced or not on the....

“Branch and his partner are displaying their weapons.” picture above, with DrB’s comment and reply.

by revival on Nov 10, 2009 7:07 PM EST up reply actions  

i'm going to

stick my fingers in your eyes

"He who becomes a beast rids the pain of being man"

by fsudt45 on Nov 10, 2009 6:56 PM EST up reply actions  

Did you guys see

what he did here? When writing FSU, instead of using an S, he used a $!!!!!!!! That is so clever! And not at all old. In fact it is very original. I laughed so hard after reading that, I almost fell off my dinosaur.

Well played, sir.

P.S. Oh! Its in his handle too!!! And he calls FSU a “bitch”!!!! This guy slays me!

by Pinto on Nov 10, 2009 7:01 PM EST up reply actions  

Boooooo.

"I'm falling apart, I'm barely breathing, With a broken heart thats still beating, In the pain is the healing, in Your Name I find meaning, So I'm holdin' on.. holdin' on to you."

by FSUvaFan on Nov 10, 2009 7:16 PM EST up reply actions  

Kinda like the joke Clemson has always been?

Do you feel confident in saying that there will be no let down for CU this season? Clemson Tigers are choke artists, its a well known fact. And if you wanna discuss fans that are a joke, I’d like to see you claim this little girl . . ..

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0WBmrrRKg-c&feature=PlayList&p=9DFB42004321E3F4&playnext=1&playnext_from=PL&index=72

by truenole87 on Nov 10, 2009 8:40 PM EST up reply actions   1 recs

REC'd or... Wrecked? (sry couldn't resist)

That clip is hilarious! I wonder how much he bet.

by Rock_and_Nole on Nov 12, 2009 11:54 AM EST up reply actions  

Andre Branch

for Eyesman..get it? eyesman (heisman)..sorry i couldn’t resist

"He who becomes a beast rids the pain of being man"

by fsudt45 on Nov 10, 2009 6:58 PM EST reply actions   1 recs

McDaniel is the real scary one

He has a weird psycho look in his eyes when he is pointing at Ponder
I must say, Ponder showed some heart running into that.

by BoobyBowden on Nov 10, 2009 7:07 PM EST reply actions  

rec'd

made me chuckle.

"The only place success comes before work is in the dictionary." Vince Lombardi

by RishiM on Nov 11, 2009 2:50 PM EST up reply actions  

McDaniel claims

he was pointing to Ponder and challenging him. He says " letting him know there was about to be a collision, man on man. Me and him on the sideline, may the best man win."

Well if the point was for Ponder to prevent him from staying in bounds and scoring, then technically, Ponder won.

by montverdenole on Nov 11, 2009 12:23 PM EST up reply actions  

Bobby pwns CU

Whats the series at now, 17-7?

by CSI Nole on Nov 10, 2009 7:18 PM EST reply actions  

He will be available next year

He’d make a good fit for Clemson, since you like taking FSU retreads in Scott, Steele, and formerly Tommy B. Clemson and U.S.C. can then battle it out at the end of the season for the title of ‘best grave yard coach program.’

by revival on Nov 10, 2009 7:48 PM EST up reply actions  

i must say

i am quite impressed. You guys have a really active community here

by BoobyBowden on Nov 10, 2009 7:26 PM EST reply actions  

Well im out then.

"I'm falling apart, I'm barely breathing, With a broken heart thats still beating, In the pain is the healing, in Your Name I find meaning, So I'm holdin' on.. holdin' on to you."

by FSUvaFan on Nov 10, 2009 9:05 PM EST up reply actions  

Now thats sticking it to the man; let freedom ring.

"I'm falling apart, I'm barely breathing, With a broken heart thats still beating, In the pain is the healing, in Your Name I find meaning, So I'm holdin' on.. holdin' on to you."

by FSUvaFan on Nov 11, 2009 7:18 AM EST up reply actions  

McDaniel pointing reminds me of Babe Ruth pointing before going yard. ’Bout the same results.

Ameica, Land of the free and home to the entitled.

by levynole on Nov 10, 2009 7:43 PM EST reply actions  

I couldn't really see much from the video

It might have been an eye gouge but it wasn’t nearly as conclusive as the Spikes video.

Definitely a dirty play though.

http://cfb-hashmarks.blogspot.com/

by HashMarks on Nov 10, 2009 8:09 PM EST reply actions  

Hey DrB,

I went and checked out Shakinthesouthland.com looks really good man. Where did you find that Bowden’s Swan Song at? That is Effin GREAT!!!

Huked On Foniks Wurks Fer ME!!!!

by PanamaCityBeach-NOLE on Nov 10, 2009 8:13 PM EST reply actions  

Great Find

Keep faith in the site man, it looks good and im sure before to long people will start to realize. I know I’ll stop by and chat with ya

Huked On Foniks Wurks Fer ME!!!!

by PanamaCityBeach-NOLE on Nov 10, 2009 8:19 PM EST up reply actions  

C'mon guys

It was an honest mistake! He just didn’t realize then when you help someone off the ground by the chin you shouldn’t be sitting on his back.

by Renegade_NOL3 on Nov 10, 2009 9:04 PM EST reply actions  

Andre's Statement on FB:

Andre Branch For everyone who dont know i didnt eyegauge the player from Florida State, lets get that cleared up I was just caught up in the moment pulled his helmet and facemask my hand never went into the facemask for everyone that wants to no the truth 40

by coonhound on Nov 10, 2009 10:00 PM EST reply actions  

It’s used by optometrists to measure eye pressure. How do you not know this?

by evenflow58 on Nov 11, 2009 10:07 AM EST up reply actions  

Seems like

He tried it but wasn’t smart enough to figure it out.

Points for effort though, I guess

by PBD on Nov 11, 2009 9:44 AM EST up reply actions  

I suspect that like many College Football fans, Mr. Branch is a closet TN reader.

And I may have tainted his response by suggesting it to him earlier in the day with that post.

Either way, if your guy commits a dumb act like Mr. Branch’s, it was just being, “caught up in the moment.” Whatever the f that means.

Sorry about getting all roach ragey on your ass and taking a baseball bat to your windshield, “I was just caught up in the moment.”

Sorry about saying your wife is a crack-whore, “I was just caught up in the moment.”

Sorry about spitting in your face Mr. Hirschbeck, “I was just caught up in the moment.”

Sorry about cold-clocking you in the face, Rudy Tomjanovich, “I was just caught up in the moment.”

Sorry about kicking you in the nuts Mr. Basketball Photographer Man, “I was just caught up in the moment.”

Sorry about hiring a hit on your ass and having my associates club your leg with a steel pipe, Ms. Kerigan, “I was just caught up in the moment.”

Sorry about hitting you in the temple with my hockey stick, Mr. Brashear, “I was just caught up in the moment.”

It’s such a lame, but strangely enough, well-accepted excuse for absurd behavior by athletes.

by coonhound on Nov 11, 2009 6:18 PM EST up reply actions   1 recs

Have you ever thought about becoming a sports writer?

Now lemme clarify, i know you are and i think you do a WONDERFUL job here. But being that just about EVERY Sports Writers here in Florida are Grad of UF i think you’de be a sweet relief to all us who read local newspapers. You are doin above and beyond my friend!!! +1000

Huked On Foniks Wurks Fer ME!!!!

by PanamaCityBeach-NOLE on Nov 10, 2009 11:23 PM EST up reply actions  

WOW!!!

my uncle had told me you were in law school but i didnt let it sink in at that time. How on earth do you balance that with all you put into here? muli-tasker!!!

Huked On Foniks Wurks Fer ME!!!!

by PanamaCityBeach-NOLE on Nov 10, 2009 11:31 PM EST up reply actions  

No suspension per the ACC...

ACC offices and Clemson coach Dabo Swinney both reviewed the tapes only to conclude no suspension was warranted. Must have concluded that Branch wasn’t trying to gouge out the Spurlock’s eyes out but was trying to keep him from getting to the fumble as was Branch’s side of the story. Excessive, yes. Penalty warranted, yes. Does this and worse happen all the time on fumbles, yes.

Two other points: Are Spikes and Branch just so terribly uncoordinated that they couldn’t gouge out the eyes of someone who was in unable to shield their eyes? How many eyes have been gouged out in football history?

by slingle on Nov 11, 2009 2:12 PM EST reply actions  

That'll do.....

Karmas a b%#$ on her period who won't let ya see the kids on the weekend! I suspect she'll visit Mr. Branch soon enough. Until then, i'll remind everyone of the s^* list being compiled. Yes Andre Branch did indeed make the list w/ this crap. Truthfully, our boys were just as mean back when we had our"swagger". Although I cant recall any of ours poking eyes like the Waterboy. Not saying it didn’t happen, just that i don’t remember seeing it. Regarding the two other points, I dont think either was actually trying to remove an eye(which is surprisingly easy to do) I think these “gouges” fall under the category of touching the eye(which is one of the most personal things you can do to another human) thus angering an individual to the point of making a mental error. Also, keep in mind, if you get dirt,sand, etc. in your eye you may sit a play or not due your job as effectively as necessary. Either way, it has been viewed (by some)as an eye gouge and can’t be a positive for Clemson.

by Scalpemall on Nov 11, 2009 3:02 PM EST up reply actions  

There was no eye-gouge...get over yourselves.

First & foremost, I do not hide the fact that I am a Clemson fan, but but what I am about to say has nothing to do w/fan loyalty. Any objective person would come away w/the same conclusion. The only people who say otherwise are FSU fans who can’t come to terms w/the result of last Saturday’s game, & people who don’t like football b/c they think it’s too violent & are always looking for something like this to prove their point.

1 – Personally, when I look @ the tape I think Branch was trying to pull Spurlock up/back so that he could not cover the fumble. I say that b/c he immediately does that when the 2 players dive @ the ball. Branch lets go & gets up very quickly afterward when it’s obvious that someone else recovered the ball. Regardless of the reason/intent, I do not defend what Branch did b/c it was uncalled for. I don’t condone any of it b/c it’s unecessary and potentially harmful.

Having said that, I played football at a highly competitive level from Pop Warner through high school (didn’t have the size to play D1 & didn’t want to play at a lower level), so I know exactly how contentious “the pile” can be. For those of you who’ve never played football (especially competitive football), this happens in EVERY game, by EVERY team. There are no exceptions. In fact, for every Brandon Spikes-type incident, you have at least half a dozen incidents (minimum…easily) that go unnoticed.

These incidents always occur as an attempt to gain an edge, & they take 2 forms – the aggressor, & the retaliator. Which one was Branch? Did he act unprovoked, or was he retaliating for something? Another quick note for those of you who’ve never played football or fought w/a sibling or witnessed 2 siblings fight…a lot of times you never see “what started it”, you only see the reaction of the retaliator. Furthermore, unless you happen to line up across from the person every play (& sometimes even if you do), you may not get an opportunity for immediate retaliation. You might have to spend the rest of the game waiting for an opportunity to present itself. Again, I’m not condoning what Branch did, or accusing Spurlock of instigating anything; I’m just pointing out what often happens & the fact that we may not have the whole story.

2 – HOWEVER!!!!! As indefensible as what Branch did was, what he DID & what so many people are CLAIMING he did are 2 different things. Branch DID yank/hyperextend Spurlock’s head/neck/back. Branch DID NOT eye-gouge Spurlock. You can see this @ live speed, but ironically the still-shot that you provide as “proof” of eye-gouging is actually more proof that he did no such thing.

As you can see by the still-shot, Branch is wearing gloves…and as most gloves go, each one is identical to its counterpart. What’s important about this point is that you can clearly see by Branch’s left hand (which is completely outside of Spurlock’s facemask) that his glove has a Nike Swoosh that goes to the first knuckle. You can clearly see that very same Swoosh on the glove on Branch’s right hand. This means 2 important things – Branch’s hand was parallel to the camera & facemask, AND @ MOST the ONLY PART of Branch’s hand that could possibly have been inside Spurlock’s helmet were his fingers. Of course, if you look closer, you can actually tell that 2 of Branches right fingers are outside the facemask, but for sake of the argument, we’ll pretend you can’t see that. In any case, what am I getting @? What does any of this mean?

Since you can see the Swoosh, that means that his hand was parallel to the camera and facemask. This means that even IF he were trying to gouge, his hand would only be able to go as far as the facemask before being blocked by the mask. The only thing left to go inside the facemask would be Branch’s fingers. Also, Branch’s hand is on the part of the facemask that is furthest away from Spurlock’s eyes. Branch would have to have fingers like Arsenio Hall to even touch Spurlock’s face, much less gouge anything. If Branch’s hand were perpendicular to Spurlock’s facemask, THEN he would be able to gouge b/c he would be able to push his hand further inside the mask.

The bottom line is, as Dabo Swinney says, we live in a hyper-sensitive. You people are either looking for a story to pin your FSU frustrations on, looking to discredit Clemson for some reason or looking to make a statement about society as a whole. Either way this is largely a non-issue.

by Schitzngrins on Nov 13, 2009 3:51 PM EST reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to Tomahawk Nation, your home for no-holds-barred analysis of FSU Athletics. Remember the Community Guidelines.
Start posting about the Seminoles »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

Connect_with_facebook

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

Small
FSU Football WX Outlook
Seminole_small
Continuing the Zone Discussion: An Amateurs Breakdown
_1_small
Ongoing Discussion Thread #30
Greg_reid_small
2011 Recruiting Discussion Thread #9

Recent FanPosts

Th_theuez_small
If Boise State played an ACC Schedule...
Small
My own personal Urban Meyer story
Th_theuez_small
It's finally time for the ACC to take center stage.
29seminoles
Tomahawk Nation Pick'em Get in today!
Small
My Take on JWJ
Small
Lack of attendance part 2
Laughing-man_small
2010 TN T-Shirts?

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

SBNation.com Recent Stories

Utah wide receiver Jereme Brooks (85) celebrates a touchdown with teammates during the first half of an NCAA college football game against Pittsburgh on Thursday, Sept. 2, 2010, in Salt Lake City. (AP Photo/Steve C. Wilson)

No. 15 Pittsburgh Rallies In Fourth Quarter, But Loses To Utah In Overtime, 27-24

HONOLULU - SEPTEMBER 2:  Ronald Johnson #83 of the University of Southern California Trojans runs in for a touchdown against Corey Nielsen #8 of the University of Hawaii Warriors during first half action at Aloha Stadium September 2 2010 in Honolulu Hawaii. (Photo by Kent Nishimura/Getty Images)

Lane Kiffin Is Victorious In Debut, No. 14 USC Wins In A Shootout At Hawaii, 49-36

South Carolina quarterback Stephen Garcia, left, celebrates a first-quarter touchdown with South Carolina tackle Kyle Nunn, center, and South Carolina guard Rokevious Watkins, right, during the first half of their NCAA college football game against Southern Mississippi, Thursday, Sept. 2, 2010, at Williams-Brice Stadium, in Columbia, S.C.  (AP Photo/Brett Flashnick) link

South Carolina Rolls Over Southern Miss, Wins 41-13

More from SBNation.com >


Chiefs

Img_4552_small TrueCubbie

29seminoles Bud Elliott

Editors

Miller_small basaltrock

446905_small nolesblogger

Small Fsued

Doak_1968_small pbysh

Small CaStauch

Vacation_013_small MattDNole

Mickey_a_small FSUSOM

Frank_the_tank_small DKfromVA

Peter_ernie_small The K-Man

_1_small FrankDNole

Robbowtiedrink_small ricobert1

Florida-county-map_small SWFLNole.

Highlife_small fsu44

Moderators

Peter_warrick_small TRMNole

Seminoleswag_small NoleLaw