In the Treatment Room: A Discussion About Anterior Cruciate Ligament (ACL) Injuries
In August, we learned that Tavares Pressley tore his Anterior Cruciate Ligament (ACL) in practice and would be out for the remained of the season.
In the second installment of the In the Treatment Room series, we take a look at the dreaded ACL injury and what to expect from Tavares.

One of the most well recognized injuries in sports is a tear/rupture of the Anterior Cruciate Ligament (ACL). Unfortunately, Tavares Pressley tore his during practice this year, which is not a common event as most ACL injuries occur during game situations. I don't know the specific circumstances in which the injury occured. Many discussions about sports injuries discuss tendons and ligaments. Ligaments connect bones together to create joints. For example, the elbow contains the Medial Collateral Ligament of the elbow, which is commonly injured in throwing athletes. Your shoulder is composed of many ligaments including the scapulohumeral ligaments that connect your shoulder blade to the bone in your upper arm. When you sprain your ankle, you injure a ligament. Tendons, on the other hand, connect muscle to bone. Your Achilles Tendon attaches your calf muscles to your heel bone. Your biceps tendon attaches your bicep to your forearm. Injuries to both Tendons and Ligaments occur in the form of partial or complete tears. Tendons get "irritated" resulting in a tendonitis. Sometimes the terms tendons and ligaments are interchanged and that is not correct.
In the United States, there are approximately 200,000 ACL related injuries each year. 95,000 of those are complete ruptures of the ligament. There are almost 100,000 ACL reconstructions performed each year. The sports typically associated with ACL injury include football, basketball skiing and soccer. Surprsingly, girls injure their ACLs at a rate 2-9 times higher than boys. This difference has been studied in detail and there is no specific evidence for a specific cause, however it is likely realted to intrinsic (joint laxity, joint alignment, ligament size) and extrinsic factors (strength and coordination, level of skill and conditioning and shoe-surface interface).
There was a recent study out of the University of Pittsburgh and the University of Wisconsin printed in the American Journal of Orthopedics last year that specifically looked at the rate of knee injuries in elite football players. They evaluated 332 college football players at the 2005 combine (it takes a while for research to make it through the submission process to be published in the scientific literature). 54% of the players had a history of a knee injury and the total number of knee injuries was 233, which averages out to 1.3 injuries per player injured. Eighty-Six players (25.9%) had some form of surgery. The most common injuries were to the medial colateral ligament, meniscus and the ACL. The two most common surgeries were meniscus repair and ACL reconstruction, occuring in 39 and 35 players respectively. The positions that had the highest rate of knee injury, not exclusively ACL, were the following: Defenisve lineman (68% of players), tight ends (57%) and offensive linemen (57%). However, running backs and line backers were more likely to have surgery. Of the 36 running backs they evaluated 36% of them had knee surgery. Of the 35 linebackers evaluated, 34% of them had surgery. The position with the least number of knee surgeries was the Quarterback (8.3%). Think about that...out of 332 players at the 2005 NFL Combine, 25% of them had knee surgery.
Your ACL is one of the major structural components of your knee, connecting your femur (thigh bone) to your tibia (shin bone). The ligament is only abou 38mm in length and 10mm in width. It runs from the the posteromedial corner of the medial aspect of the lateral femoral condyle to the interspinous area on the tibia. Meaning in runs from the back (posterior) of your knee on your femur (your thigh bone) to the groove that is in the middle of the top portion of your tibia (shin bone). Here's a picture:

Image from here.
Here is a nice video that shows you all of the ligaments in the knee with an explanation of their function.
Another way to think about it is if you take your right hand and cross your third finger over your second finger. This resembles the positioning of your PCL and ACL in your left knee. Your ACL is represented by your 2nd finger and your Posterior Cruciate Ligament (PCL) is represented by your 3rd finger. PCL injury is very uncommon and does not require repair except in elite level athletes. The Anterior and Posterior designations refer to where the ligaments insert into the tibia.
Your ACL helps to prevent anterior displacement of your tibia from your femur, meaning it helps to prevent your shin from moving too far forward. Look at the way the ligament runs from the back of the femur to the front of the tibia. The ligament is tightest when the knee is extended (straightened). There are other subtleties to how the ligament is taught or lax depending on the degree at which the knee is bent, but that isn't important for this discussion.
ACL injuries typically occur when there is a significant shearing force applied to the ligament due to quardriceps contraction, particularly when the knee is in a position of extension. This usually occurs in a non-contact deceleration movement that occus with some component of twist. Imagine your running back trying to make a quick juke or lateral move during a decelration. Others describe it as an athlete landing and then trying to quickly pivot in the opposite direction.
When the injury occurs, there is often a pop that is heard. A few hours after the injury, there is significant swelling that results from a hemarthrosis (blood in the joint). There is a classic triad of injury, referred to as the "terrible triad" that occurs when a force is applied to the side of the knee (a player being cut block or a lineman having another player role up on his knee) that results in an ACL, MCL and medical meniscus tear.
Here are some videos of plays on which ACL injuries occured: Not for the faint of heart.
A torn ACL can be detected on physical exam with the following tests: (Click on the links to see videos)
The ACL can also be vsiulaized on MRI. Here is a normal MRI: (Hint the red arrow is pointing to the ACL.

Photo from here.
Here is an abnormal MRI:

Photo from Rice University
The two images are using different MRI techniques. I am not going to get into the physics of MRI here. If you're interested, email me. But the ACL that is highlited in this picture should be the same color (density) as the PCL that is highlited. Also note, that the wavy ACL is not connected where it should be on the back of the ACL. That is a complete rupture of the ligament.
If an ACL is ruptured it need to be repaired or else the joint is going to be very unstable. If the ligament goes unrepaired, you typically get meniscal tears (the padding in the knee joint) and degenerative joint disease. There are a variety of operative repairs. All of the surgeries essentially replace the damaged tendon with a donor tendon. That tendon could come from the patient or from a cadaver.
Here is a cartoon video of one kind of repair, using a graft from the patient's patellar (knee) tendon.
Here is a real video of an ACL repair. If you have a quesy stomach don't watch this as it is real. Pretty amazing that all of this is being done through a tiny camera. The recovery period requires significant ammount of therapy in order to regain strength and stability of the knee joint. The Therapy is divided into four categories:
1. Phase 1: (Preoperative) Goal to regain full range of motion.
2. Phase 2 (0-2 Weeks): Achieve full extension, maintain quad control and minimize swelling, achieve ful extension (straight leg)
3. Phase 3: (3-5 weeks) Maintain full extension and increase flexion (bending) to full range of motion. Stair climbers and bicycles may be used.
4. Phase 4: (Six weeks plus) Increase strength and agility, progressive return to sports, which may take up to 6-9 months depending on the level of activity desired.
Athletes can typically return to their previous level of competition, though it might be at a slighlty reduced level of competition. In one study, 100% of athletes were able to return to the NFL after an ACL injury. Here is an interesting article about specific injuries and NFL careers. Here is a really nice article that looks at NFL running backs stats pre- and post- ACL injury.
Hope this helps you to have a better understanding of ACL injuries. It looks like Tavares should be back in time for the regular season. He will have had almost a year recovery period and should be close to his previous level of competition.
0 recs |
35 comments
|
Comments
Damn that must have took a while to write...
I can barely follow it. I guess that’s why I’m an accounting major. =)
Thanks for the reminder...
of why I didn’t go to med school. I got queasy just reading some of this.
I about threw up in the "Flag football"
video. I couldn’t watch any more of them. The “pop” is the signature of the ACL tear.
"I have come that you may have life, and life to the max"
I wish I could wave a magic wand
and eliminate the ACL injury from football. It’s so easy to do, and consistently takes so long to recover. I hate it for anybody that’s ever experienced this. I’ve been a fraidy cat and avoiding playing any more competitive flag football for fear of this injury I’ve been lucky to avoid my whole life.
A few years ago, I played in my last organized flag football league. About 2/3’s of the way through the season, I had a significant mole removed from my back and didn’t play that night. A kid from my office filled in and proceeded to tear his ACL on the third play of the game.
I tore my ACL in October..
..and I’ve learned more about my injury/recovery in reading this than in 5 months of doctors visits. This is great, thanks.
Great Read TC...
I tore my MCL in November playing soccer but thankfully the MCL is a ligament that given time will eventually repair itself. it seems like it has taken forever as i’m still not even 80% yet. Thankfully something like this never happened to me while playing in college bc i wouldnt be able to handle all of the time off. I really feel for Tavares and any other athletes who have had to deal with an injury like this.
Man, I'm surprised to hear about all the knee injuries just among the TN faithful.
“…out of 332 players at the 2005 NFL Combine, 25% of them had knee surgery.” Assuming that’s accurate, that shocked me.
This is a great writeup.
I echo jab in saying I’m glad I chose not to go to med school.
I found this article , which I think can be attributed to the mental or trust aspect of recovery as opposed to the actual surgery:
The good news for NFL players who sustain an injury to their anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) is that they’ll likely play again in the NFL. The bad news is, they’ll return with diminished performance on the field, concludes a study in the December issue of The American Journal of Sports Medicine.
I know I’m finding it somewhat tough to trust my shoulder again and am consistently surprised at what I can do now that I could not do even two weeks ago.
Thanks again, TC.
THANK YOU PERCOCET and BEER
Always helped me do things I normally cant do. Im sorry I misunderstood what you were saying. hehehe
Why is the sky blue? Because, God Loves the Infantry
Awesome writeup
TC you are the man. While I am an accountant and have no use for knowing this much about the ACL, or anything this detailed about the human body, my fiance is a physical therapist so I get my daily dose of it from her. I am constantly quizzing her on sports-related injuries and the like. While she would rather not assume a diagnosis, she will however give me specifics on what route she would take during the rehab process. Again this was a great post
This is a good read.
I work with a lot of sport injuries at work with soldiers going through basic training. You are right on the money. I dont see a lot of tears but I see a lot of strains and MCL and LCL problems. more of the runners knee stuff. Its a long process for those to heal with an NSAID, Ice and elevation, so I could only guess the ACL takes a lot longer time and prob more painful. Also with the test if they start to ball or punch you while doing them thats a good sign too for a Pos test.
Why is the sky blue? Because, God Loves the Infantry
After reading this and for the first time in my life, I will understand what the different injuries mean,
since I was fortunate enough to never have required surgery for any of my injuries.
TC, REAL NICE JOB.
My pleasure. I enjoy writing about this stuff and hope it sheds some light on the lingo that is tossed around.
As other injuries come up I will write about them. If there are any other specific injuries that come to mind or any other sports medicine related issues e-mail me and I will put together some information. I know we have all be talking about Diabetes and sports related performance, is that something you all would like to learn more about?
Are we limited to football-type injuries?
If not, I’d like to know more about Tommy John surgery, if you don’t mind.
by basbalstr101 on Apr 9, 2009 11:32 PM EDT up reply actions
Not limited to football...pick any sport, injury, question...your pic....this is for you guys.
Tommy John surgery is a great idea.
If you’re into baseball pitching mechanics and injury prevention and such, take a look at www.drivelinemechanics.com It’s an SBNation blog that breaks down pitching and hitting motions. Beautiful analysis over there.
how about ankle injuries?
Since you have gone so in depth I could find out what the heck happened to me when i had the worst sprain of all time. Also pertinent when looking at how Manu on the spurs just lost the rest of his season with an injury there.
Great write-ups TC. Where do you find the time?
Any specific ankle injuries you had in mind? Sprains? Fractures?
Let me know. Happy to write about any or all of the above. Just needs to be specific as there are text books on the ankle. Glad you enjoyed it.
It helps that I’m in the industry so I already have a base of information and know where to look for more. Makes things go a little bit faster. Plus I enjoy it.
A few years ago
I was running around 2nd and my ankle gave out. First sprain ever, and it was an awful one. A week later, leaving the bar, a girl was pulling me out faster then I could crutch, and I sprained the other one. I can still crack both ankles… So yea, would like to know what causes em to be so fickle.
So the girl was pulling you out of the bar so fast you sprained your ankle?
I’d like to try to help, but you’re going to have to tell me what the problem is.
Well yea..
I mean, that was nice (it was a bullwinkles night, you know the back, tricky step goin out) but it was irritating to sprain the other one.
and rounding 2nd, that wasnt a metaphor, I was at a park (cant remember the name of it) haha.
TRM, you sly boots.
Isn't Tommy John surgery what Dekoda Watson recently had?
I found that strange because I can’t remember any other football player having it done, only pitchers to the best of my knowledge.
Some more ideas for future articles...
Shin splints, bone spurs, tennis elbow, turf toe, differences between strained/pulled muscles
I am really interested in sports related injuries. These topics don’t seem to be as complex as the ACL injury, and some may be too simple for these articles. Just thought I’d throw out some common injuries we hear about in athletes.
shin splints +1
yea, and how to stop getting them would be great. I mean, just out of curiosity, its not like I get those or anything…cough
shin splints sucks I know from first hand
there are a few websites like Medscape and healthline that are good for med stuff.
Why is the sky blue? Because, God Loves the Infantry
I had bad shin splints in high school.
I tried to “wrap” them on the advice of some, but that didn’t help at all.
My understanding is that a shin splint occurs when the muscle begins to pull or tear away from the bone. The advice that worked for me included strengthening your calf muscle by doing calf raises or some other similar exercise. The explanation given to me also seemed to make sense. Then again, I’m not a doctor…
yes and no
you are right but what is going on is the calf muscle is getting bigger and pulls away from the Tibia. If you dont stretch good everyday it gets tight and starts to rip away. This causes the dual pain that hurts the more you use it and if you go to long you could get a stress Fx and take a long time to heal.
The Treatment is the same for most muscle skeletal pain. Rest, ICE, eleaviate, your choice of NSID (IBU/motrin or naproxin/alive) and stretch, stretch, stretch. Compessing isnt really going to do much and is only good for major swelling like post OP stuff or knee and ankle stuff
Why is the sky blue? Because, God Loves the Infantry
a friend told me to put on ICY/HOT before I started to run
I would love to start doin cardio again, but I always have to stop before I am tired because my shins start to feel like they are going to snap.
well I have good news for you
All you need to do is go to a gym and use an elliptic machine. Its a low to zero impact on your knees and when people have ankle and shin problems you wont strain the muscles and tendons. I run a lot in the Army and when I get them (Im lazy and dont ever stretch like I should) I use this machine when I have them. Its a great cardio workout. I started with 15min for about 2-3 days then moved up to 30 min.(Most people say you should at least do 20min of a cardio workout) then when you are good at 30min you can move up to 45min. If you want to work your gluteus maximus or butt for the ladys, all you have to do is stop every 5 min and change directions. (going backwards works the butt out good) You will feel the work out about for the first 2-3 days then your use to it and start to feel good. Its easy to use and really good. Last, you can use it 3 times a week but can use it 6 or 7 days. your leg muscles heal ever 18-24 hr so you can do cardio everday unlike upperbody stuff where you should work out every other day.
Why is the sky blue? Because, God Loves the Infantry
Thanks Des
When I was a member of a gym, i used the elliptical. Cant afford the gym with my school bills, and the school gym is a bit lacking.
Can you tell me some good stretches so that I can do some running without feeling like I’ll need new legs?
Thanks for the other tips though, they will def be implemented.
Ill see what I can get from work
I know the best for me is to put you toes or the ball of your feet on a ledge or bookshelf and hold onto something and hang down with your weight pulling on your calf. Thats prob the best for me give each leg about 45-60sec and groin stretches will help out good with running.
Why is the sky blue? Because, God Loves the Infantry





























